7 Best Coffee Shops in Monticello, New York

Description: Tilly's offers a classic diner atmosphere with authentic decor and food reminiscent of the 1950s. Guests can enjoy hearty portions, fresh ingredients, and friendly service. Despite minor issues like poorly cooked orders or backups, their coffee is well-regarded, and overall dining experience remains inviting for those seeking nostalgia and comfort.

Description: The coffee shop offers a wide variety of pastries and sandwiches, catering to different tastes with options for both lunch and breakfast. Known for its friendly service and delicious food, it's an excellent choice for those looking for high-quality, locally made treats. Despite having limited seating, the establishment manages to keep things moving efficiently during peak hours.

Description: This Dunkin' location offers quick service and ample parking, but faces issues with freshness and quality, particularly regarding donuts served after 4 PM and coffees received at times when they should be fresh. The atmosphere is clean and spacious, though there's a noticeable inconsistency in the quality of food across different visits. Staff seem friendly but can struggle with reading instructions clearly or addressing customer concerns effectively.

Description: The coffee shop offers consistently good food and service, with standout experiences from top-tier staff like Christian and Kevin. However, issues persist with order accuracy and timely service, especially during peak hours, which can detract from an otherwise positive dining experience. The atmosphere is welcoming, though parking can be challenging at busy times.

Description: Savory Sweet offers mouthwatering homemade dishes and exceptional service, from freshly baked pastries to perfectly cooked burgers. The friendly owner takes pride in her culinary creations, which leave guests satisfied with every bite. Whether you're stopping by for a coffee or ordering in, Savory Sweet creates an inviting atmosphere that ensures memorable dining experiences.

Description: Bella Cafe offers an inviting atmosphere with attentive staff and perfectly crafted drinks, from expertly made lattes to delightful pastries like heart-shaped straws and crepes. The café's cozy patio makes it a perfect spot for enjoying coffee on a sunny day, and the friendly service elevates every visit. Known for its high-quality beverages and warm customer experience, Bella Cafe stands out as a local favorite where both casual visitors and loyal patrons appreciate their commitment to excellence.