3 Best Coffee Shops in Locust Valley, New York (2025 Guide)

This cozy cafe offers a warm and inviting atmosphere, known for its delicious home-made dressings and salads. Whether you're enjoying lunch or dinner, patrons often appreciate the attentive service and quick turnaround times from the welcoming staff. Located in Locust Valley, it's a charming spot that caters to both regulars and visitors looking for tasty treats and beverages.

Basil Leaf offers an authentic Italian dining experience with exquisite food and impeccable service, set against a charming ambiance reminiscent of a European village. Their warm bread and diverse menu cater to both casual diners and those looking for a special evening out, though some patrons have complained about staff attitude issues. The establishment prides itself on its generous portions and thoughtful details like complimentary parking.

Karmic Grind Coffee offers a cozy, inviting space with ample seating for studying or relaxing. The staff is friendly and attentive, always providing excellent service. With a variety of drinks, including their signature matcha latte and sea salt caramel latte, along with delicious baked goods like croissants, it's a go-to spot for both coffee enthusiasts and those seeking a leisurely meal.