25 Best Coffee Shops in Indiana (2025 Guide)

Brickhouse Coffee Company offers an inviting atmosphere with its unique and tasty offerings including housemade syrups and freshly baked goods. Patrons appreciate the quiet ambiance, ample outdoor seating options, and helpful staff who assist in navigating their extensive menu. Despite some higher prices, the coffee is consistently praised for being delicious, making it a standout choice for both casual sipping and more leisurely meals or work sessions.

Firefly Coffee House offers a cozy atmosphere with creative beverages and friendly service. Artfully decorated walls enhance the ambiance, while pleasant staff ensure customer satisfaction. Despite occasional overpriced items, the food and drinks are generally good, especially notable for their sourdough bread served every Saturday morning. Its quirky charm makes it ideal for hanging out, studying, or just enjoying a relaxed meal with family and friends.

Cock A Doodle Cafe stands out as a hometown diner with its friendly staff and large portions that fill the bill for hearty meals. From expertly prepared pork tenderloin to fried mush on the menu, every dish meets expectations of a classic American diner. The place feels cozy and welcoming, especially appreciated by elderly patrons who frequent its doors. Despite occasional service hiccups, Cock A Doodle Cafe offers great food and a nostalgic dining experience, making it worth visiting for those seeking authentic hometown comfort.

Black Forest Cat Café offers an adorable experience where patrons can enjoy their beverages and snacks while interacting with well-cared-for feline companions. The café is known for its diverse range of cats with unique personalities that love affection. Patrons get to brush and play, making the visit feel like a playful yet responsible petting zoo. With vegan accommodations and knowledge about drink ingredients alongside animal education, it stands out as an inclusive and compassionate café environment.

Chicory Cafe offers an inviting environment with comfortable vibes and diverse menu options that appeal to various tastes. The café serves good food paired with drinks in a relaxed setting where live entertainment occasionally adds to the atmosphere. Despite some initial hesitation due to lack of greeting, it quickly becomes clear that the friendly staff aims to make every guest feel welcome. While there's room for improvement regarding cleanliness and furniture, the overall experience highlights Chicory Cafe as a place worth revisiting.

Main Street Roasters offers a delightful ambiance with various seating options for enjoying coffee and conversation. The food is widely praised, especially the pastries that are homemade every day. Friendly staff make any visit enjoyable, while the selection of gift items adds to its appeal. Whether it's for relaxing with friends or hosting events, Main Street Roasters presents an inviting space tailored for all occasions.

Curve Cafe offers patrons a welcoming atmosphere reminiscent of classic diners with TVs for entertaining young guests. The food is consistently praised for its quality and portions are generous enough to satisfy even the largest appetites. Friendly staff members provide attentive service that makes return visits more than welcome, and whether for quick breakfasts or more substantial brunches, Curve Cafe stands out as a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Cath Coffee and Tea House presents an outstanding experience with its diverse menu offering both classic and unique drinks prepared with high-quality ingredients. The friendly service and meticulous presentation of seasonal options set it apart from more popular chains like Starbucks. Homemade pastries add another layer of appeal, making every visit worth the trip to Castleton Square Mall. With prices competitive yet better than Starbucks, Cath Coffee and Tea House stands out as a go-to spot for coffee enthusiasts and casual shoppers alike.

Old Crown Coffee Roasters offers an inviting atmosphere with a cozy blend of rustic charm and modern elements. Known for its high-quality coffee made in-house, this establishment has become a local favorite. The menu includes both simple treats like snacks and wraps alongside more substantial items. Despite the slow kitchen service at times, the friendly staff ensure patrons enjoy their visits, making it a standout spot for coffee lovers and casual diners alike.

Coat Check Coffee is an intriguing and charming coffee shop that defies the ordinary. Housed in what appears to be a coat check area from another era, its cozy yet unique setting invites patrons to savor both its history and current offerings. Exceptionally crafted lattes and pastries underscore the attention to detail, while the inviting atmosphere makes it a standout spot for coffee enthusiasts and those seeking a memorable break. Its diverse menu caters to all preferences, especially benefiting vegetarians with a large selection of plant-based options.

Kanela Blended Drinks Coffee and Bites offers an inviting atmosphere with warm and friendly service. The café features fresh, hot food along with customizable drinks that cater to various tastes. Families appreciate the kid-friendly menu options and accommodating staff who recommend vegetarian dishes clearly labeled for vegetarians. Despite being located in a tight space, Kanela manages its brisk pace efficiently, ensuring customers enjoy their visits even as they navigate the colder winter months by providing cozy seating.

Sunshine Café in Muncie offers delightful food and warm service, making dining experiences memorable. Patrons appreciate the clean environment and the friendly staff who cater to various dietary needs. Despite occasional issues with service, especially during peak hours when waiting times can be long for takeout orders, Sunshine Café remains a go-to choice for many locals looking for quality meals at reasonable prices.

Java Haute stands out with its welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff who support local artists. The place offers great coffee and delicious baked goods at reasonable prices, making it a popular spot for both locals and visitors. With ongoing decorations by local artists and a diverse menu including seasonal flavors, Java Haute creates an inviting environment that encourages spending time there.

The Electric Brew in Downtown Goshen offers an inviting atmosphere with its large selection of drinks and food served well. Both the decor and coffee quality are praised for providing a cozy place to work remotely or simply enjoy. The café's service is noted for being excellent, and baristas consistently provide top-notch assistance and attention. Despite not ordering their lavender matcha again due to color preference, customers still appreciate other menu items like chicken salad sandwiches and cinnamon rolls.

The Mocha Nut Coffee Shop boasts an inviting ambiance that's perfect for study sessions or casual visits. Customers rave about the exceptional mocha drink and delicious pastries; one standout experience was receiving liquid gold in their cup, described by many as creamy and utterly delightful. Parking is free and plentiful, making it easy to visit whenever needed, with friendly staff ensuring a positive environment every time.

Calvin Fletcher's Coffee Company offers a serene space for work or relaxation with its inviting atmosphere and stylish decor. Known for excellent coffee and friendly service, it’s perfect for those seeking a unique café experience in the area, offering comfortable seating along with plenty of outlets for laptops. The diverse menu includes notable treats like their cinnamon rolls, which are lauded as possibly the best around.

Fortezza Coffee offers a cozy space with varied seating options and a vibrant atmosphere. Known for its unique espresso setup through a mod bar, customers enjoy a wide selection of coffees. The place also serves breakfast dishes and has an array of baked goods and snacks to choose from. Regulars frequent the establishment, contributing to its laid-back vibe and friendly service, making it a pleasant spot for both work and socializing.

Yafa Golden Coffee offers an inviting atmosphere with various seating options both indoors and out. The menu features tasty selections of coffee and pastries including the popular Dubai chocolate bar items. Staff provide excellent service, ensuring customers enjoy their visit. Despite some room organization issues, the overall experience is highly recommended for its unique Yemen experience and great value.

Penny Lane Coffeehouse offers a welcoming atmosphere with vintage clothes, art, books, and jewelry on display, making it stand out in the heart of Evansville's historic district. Known for its great service and fresh breakfast sandwiches, customers appreciate both their coffee and chi tea offerings. Despite occasional disappointments with iced coffee temperature, the overall friendly environment keeps patrons coming back, though some find its vibe more suited to a specific group of people.

MOTW Coffee and Pastries offers an inviting atmosphere with beautiful artwork featuring ancestral icons, soothing music, and warm service from staff who make everyone feel welcome. The place features minimalist yet modern decor, providing ample seating options for a relaxed reading or studying session, meditation or prayer room available. Multiple menu items are available along with various activities, making it a versatile spot that people look forward to visiting and exploring further.

UNITED COFFEE stands out with its cozy yet homey industrial space, where friendly staff welcome every customer with open arms. Their Liege waffles, crafted in-house and smelled from the moment you walk in, are hands-down favorite treats. The coffee is expertly brewed and their Italian hot chocolate offers a unique taste hard to find elsewhere. Despite being busy, patrons still enjoy ample space for conversation, making each visit memorable.

Chronic Coffee & Smoothies offers a charming vibe with its bright and welcoming atmosphere. The friendly staff makes customers feel right at home, whether ordering specialty drinks or fresh pastries. With a variety of options on the menu ranging from coffee to smoothies, everyone can find something they enjoy here. Chronic Coffee & Smoothies is a place where locals and tourists alike can support a local gem with their visits.

Falls Perk Coffee House greets visitors with an inviting aroma of freshly brewed coffee, promising an exceptional experience. The interior blends rustic charm with modern touches, including soft lighting and comfortable seating that seamlessly combines functionality with comfort. Whether for reading, connecting with friends, or working quietly, it caters to various needs. Adding to its appeal are the delightful treats available, making it a favorite spot for both locals and travelers alike.

Bovaconti Coffee offers an elegant and stylish environment with plenty of seating inside and out. It features mesmerizing coffee drinks, from the Mayan Mocha with its spicy kick to the Bronze Latte's warm turmeric flavors. The atmosphere is described as top-notch, enhanced by books and quirky items for socializing. Consistently praised for its quality and service, Bovaconti has won over customers who appreciate both its refined offerings and friendly staff.

Hopscotch Coffee & Kitchen offers a visually pleasant and aromatic experience with its elevated outdoor seating that stands out in the area. The venue splits into two sides – one for dining, conversation, and enjoying brunch, the other for coffee shop activities where students work on homework or socialize about group projects. The service is impeccable, and food choices are delicious. This place has become a go-to spot not just for coffee but also for breakfast in Bloomington's college neighborhood.